Depending on where you live – a house, apartment, or condominium – the right home insurance policy can provide you peace of mind as well as the money you need to repair or replace your home and/or belongings. The right auto insurance policy can help get you back on the road quickly if your car is damaged or destroyed by accident, fire, theft, or other covered event. Your policy may also provide protection against medical and legal expenses resulting from injury, loss of life, or property damage caused by an accident involving your vehicle.

Overmyer Hall Associates can help you find insurance that will best meet your needs and provide the most valuable combination of tailored coverage, quality service and fair pricing.

Our Home and Auto specialists serve Columbus, OH, as well as Dublin, Powell, New Albany, Westerville, Worthington, Upper Arlington and all of Central Ohio.


Protecting all the details that make your house a home:

  • Guaranteed replacement cost
  • Rebuilding to code
  • Cash settlement option
  • Appropriate loss of use limits
  • World renowned appraisal and claims services
  • A suite of complimentary and optional services

We also provide coverage for your jewelry, art and antiques, collectibles, boat and yachts.


An excess liability insurance policy provides additional layers of liability protection. If the liability limits are exhausted on your home, auto, or other underlying insurance policy, your excess liability policy takes over and provides you with additional protection.



Options and choices that are not available in most standard policies:

  • Agreed Value – you know the settlement amount of your car up front
  • Increased loss of use coverage
  • Use of Original Equipment Manufacturer parts (OEM)
  • $0 Out of pocket for glass claims


World-class coverage and claims service for the cars you collect, restore, and drive:

  • Agreed Value is included
  • You are free to use the restoration shop of your choice for covered repairs
  • Flexible usage – no fixed mileage limits
  • Optional rare or classic car parts coverage
  • Coverage during restoration available

Special pricing is also available for large collections and we provide automatic coverage for newly acquired autos worldwide.

Aryn Bates, CPRIA
Personal Lines Specialist
Phone: 614 453 9369

Questions? Ask the expert.


Our professionals are active in the following local organizations:

  • Northwest Kiwanis Club
  • Tri-Village Chamber Partnership
  • Conway Center
  • Upper Arlington Civic Association
  • Financial Planning Association